trio.so
Explained

Microsoft Entra ID (Azure AD) vs ADFS: An Overview

Microsoft Entra ID (formerly Azure AD) vs ADFS: how Microsoft's two identity solutions differ, their use cases, and the security points to consider.

Mountain landscape representing leadership perspective and vision
Written by
Atena Ladchartabi

Content writer, trio.so

Published on
Modified on
In today’s rapidly evolving digital landscape, managing user identities and access to resources has become more complex than ever. Businesses rely on robust identity management systems to ensure security, streamline user authentication, and enhance productivity. Two of the most prominent solutions from Microsoft in this space are Microsoft Entra ID (formerly Azure Active Directory, or Azure AD) and Active Directory Federation Services (ADFS). While both tools serve identity and access management purposes, they are designed for different use cases and offer unique functionalities. In this blog, we will break down the key differences, use cases, benefits, and limitations of Azure vs ADFS to help IT administrators make informed decisions.  

What is Azure’s Meaning?

Entra ID (Entra ID) is Microsoft’s cloud-based identity and access management service. It enables organizations to manage user identities, secure access to applications, and simplify single sign-on (SSO) for both on-premises and cloud applications. Entra ID serves as the backbone for authentication across Microsoft services like Office 365, Microsoft Azure, and countless third-party SaaS applications. The platform is built for cloud-native environments, providing seamless integration with modern cloud workloads. Entra ID simplifies identity management, reduces reliance on on-premises servers, and enhances overall organizational security. With Entra ID, administrators can manage user access to multiple resources through centralized authentication and authorization protocols. Additionally, Entra ID supports Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) and Conditional Access Policies, ensuring enhanced security measures are in place. Entra ID also excels in scalability, allowing organizations to extend identity services across global locations without the need for additional infrastructure.  

What is ADFS’s Meaning?

Active Directory Federation Services (ADFS) is an on-premises identity federation service from Microsoft that enables secure authentication and access management for both internal and external applications. Unlike Entra ID, which is cloud-based, ADFS is installed on on-premises servers and primarily supports Windows environments. It allows organizations to use SSO to provide users with secure access to multiple systems and applications using a single set of credentials. ADFS uses industry-standard protocols such as SAML, OAuth, and WS-Federation to enable interoperability with third-party systems. It’s particularly useful for legacy applications and environments where direct cloud integration might not be feasible. Despite its flexibility and robust security controls, ADFS authentication often requires significant infrastructure investments and ongoing maintenance, which can be challenging for smaller organizations.  

Key Differences Between Entra ID and ADFS

Entra ID (Entra ID) and Active Directory Federation Services (ADFS) are both identity management solutions from Microsoft, but they serve different purposes. Entra ID is a cloud-based identity and access management service primarily designed for managing user access to cloud resources like Microsoft 365 and other SaaS applications. In contrast, ADFS is an on-premises identity solution that uses claims-based authentication to enable Single Sign-On (SSO) for applications hosted on-premises or in the cloud. Entra ID is built for modern identity and access management needs, focusing on integration with cloud applications and services. It supports multi-factor authentication, conditional access policies, and identity protection. ADFS, on the other hand, relies on traditional Active Directory infrastructure and is better suited for organizations that require tight control over authentication and identity processes within their private network. Scalability is another key difference. Entra ID is inherently scalable due to its cloud infrastructure, making it a better choice for businesses with fluctuating user bases or global operations. ADFS, being an on-premises solution, requires organizations to maintain and scale hardware and software resources manually to accommodate growth. Finally, maintenance and updates differ significantly. Entra ID is managed and updated by Microsoft, reducing the administrative burden on IT teams. ADFS, however, requires organizations to handle updates, patches, and configuration changes internally, increasing overhead.   Computer engineer using code  

Use Cases for Entra ID

Entra ID excels in scenarios where cloud-first strategies are a priority. Organizations that rely heavily on SaaS applications like Microsoft 365, Salesforce, or Dropbox can use Entra ID to streamline authentication and user management across these platforms. Entra ID's Single Sign-On (SSO) feature simplifies access by allowing users to authenticate once and access multiple cloud-based resources without repeated logins. Another major use case for Entra ID is identity protection and advanced threat detection. With built-in tools like Conditional Access, Entra ID can enforce specific security policies based on user location, device type, and behavior patterns. This makes it an ideal choice for enterprises prioritizing robust cloud security. Entra ID is also highly effective for managing hybrid environments like server management where both on-premises and cloud resources need to be accessed seamlessly. Features like Entra Connect allow businesses to integrate their on-premises Active Directory with Entra ID, enabling smooth synchronization and consistent identity management. Additionally, Entra ID is an excellent choice for global organizations needing centralized control over identity management. Its ability to handle large-scale deployments, provide global accessibility, and offer redundancy ensures reliable and secure access for users worldwide.  

Use Cases for ADFS

ADFS is best suited for organizations with legacy systems and applications that cannot integrate directly with cloud-based identity providers like Entra ID. It allows these systems to leverage federated authentication without requiring significant application-level modifications. For enterprises with a substantial on-premises infrastructure, ADFS offers precise control over authentication workflows. In industries with strict regulatory compliance requirements—such as finance, healthcare, and government—ADFS provides a solution for maintaining authentication processes entirely within the organization's physical infrastructure. This helps ensure compliance with data sovereignty laws and other security regulations. ADFS also shines in environments where organizations need to authenticate users across multiple Active Directory domains or forests. Its claims-based authentication approach simplifies cross-domain access, making it easier to manage user identities across complex, multi-domain setups. Lastly, organizations with specific customization needs for their authentication processes often choose ADFS. Its ability to provide tailored authentication rules, claims transformations, and custom login pages allows organizations to fine-tune authentication workflows to meet unique business requirements.  

Security Considerations for Entra ID and ADFS

Both Entra ID and ADFS offer robust security measures, but their approaches differ. Entra ID prioritizes cloud security, with built-in tools for MFA, Conditional Access Policies, and identity protection mechanisms. ADFS, on the other hand, relies on an organization’s ability to maintain on-premises infrastructure securely. Misconfigurations or outdated servers can create vulnerabilities. Implementing regular audits, updating software patches, and ensuring strong authentication protocols are vital for both platforms.  

Can Organizations Choose Both?

Organizations can use both Entra ID and ADFS together, especially in hybrid identity management scenarios. Many enterprises choose this approach to leverage the strengths of both platforms—Entra ID for cloud-based services and ADFS for on-premises applications. Entra Connect bridges these two systems, ensuring seamless integration and unified identity management across cloud and on-premises environments. However, if an organization must choose one, the decision depends on its infrastructure and goals. For cloud-first organizations or those planning to migrate most of their services to the cloud, Entra ID is the clear choice. It offers scalability, reduced maintenance overhead, and native support for cloud applications, making it ideal for modern IT environments. On the other hand, organizations deeply rooted in on-premises environments with a strong dependency on legacy systems may lean towards ADFS. This is especially true if regulatory compliance requires local authentication processes or if the organization has heavily customized authentication workflows. In many cases, the hybrid approach remains the most practical solution. Organizations can start with Entra ID for cloud services while maintaining ADFS for legacy systems, gradually transitioning towards a cloud-first model as their infrastructure evolves.  

How Mobile Device Management (MDM) Solutions Enhance Entra ID and ADFS

Mobile Device Management (MDM) solutions play a critical role in enhancing the functionality and security of both Entra ID and ADFS. With Entra ID, MDM tools can enforce security policies on devices accessing cloud resources. This includes conditional access policies, encryption requirements, and device compliance checks, ensuring only secure and compliant devices can connect to organizational resources. For ADFS, MDM solutions offer similar benefits by controlling access to on-premises systems. While ADFS itself does not manage device compliance, MDM tools can act as an additional layer of verification, ensuring that only authorized devices can participate in federated authentication workflows. MDM tools also streamline user and device provisioning across both Entra ID and ADFS environments. IT administrators can enforce consistent security and authentication policies across all managed devices, whether they access cloud-based or on-premises systems. Lastly, MDM solutions enhance visibility and monitoring. Administrators can track authentication attempts, flag suspicious behavior, and quickly respond to potential breaches. This visibility is particularly valuable in hybrid environments where Entra ID and ADFS are used in tandem, as it provides a unified overview of device and user activity.  

Conclusion

Choosing between Entra ID and ADFS depends on your organization’s infrastructure, use cases, and long-term IT strategy. Entra ID excels in cloud-native environments, offering seamless scalability, enhanced security, and integration with modern cloud services. On the other hand, ADFS remains a reliable choice for on-premises systems and legacy application support. Ultimately, many businesses find value in a hybrid approach, leveraging both systems for their respective strengths. Understanding the capabilities and limitations of each will empower IT administrators to make informed decisions. Looking to simplify identity and access management for your organization? Sign up for trio.so's Free Trial today and experience secure, seamless management of your IT environment!

Ready-to-use Templates

Must-have Template Toolkit for IT Admins

Explore All
Template Toolkit

Start your free trial

No credit card required
Full access to all features

Manage Every Device From One Console

trio.so brings device management, patching and security policies for Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS/iPadOS and Android into one console. Enroll a device and see it in the console within minutes.

14-day free trial. No credit card required.

trio.so brings device management, patching and security policies for Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS/iPadOS and Android into one console. Enroll a device and see it in the console within minutes.

Smiling womanAbstract geometric patternAbstract geometric patternSmiling womanSmiling woman

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Have questions? We've got answers. This section covers some of the most commonly asked questions related to this topic.

Yes, you can try us free for 14 days. If you'd like, we'll also provide a free, personalized 30-minute onboarding call to help you get up and running quickly.

Yes, you can upgrade or downgrade your plan at any time. Changes will be reflected in your next billing cycle.

You can cancel your subscription at any time. Your account will remain active until the end of the current billing period.

Yes, you can add company details such as your business name, address, or tax ID to your invoice from your billing settings.

Billing is handled automatically based on your selected plan and billing cycle (monthly or annually). Charges are applied to the payment method you provide.

You can update your account email in your profile or account settings. A confirmation may be required for security purposes.

Related

From the blog

The related industry news, interviews, technologies, and resources.